HIDDEN GEM HORROR 20. The Devil’s Candy (Tubi, SHUDDER, AMC+) 19. Black Sheep (FreeVee, Vudu, Plex) 18. *Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum (Peacock) 17. Starry Eyes (Peacock, Plex, Roku, FreeVee) 16. Deadstream (SHUDDER, AMC+) 15. The Last Witch Hunter (FreeVee) 14. The Nightmare (FreeVee) 13. Come True (Hulu, SHUDDER, AMC+) 12. Fried Barry (SHUDDER, AMC+) 11. May (Tubi) 10. Blood Red Sky (Netflix) 9. Color Out of Space (SHUDDER, AMC+) 8. Summer of 84 (SHUDDER, AMC+) 7. Pledge (AMC+) 6. Haunt (Prime Video, Hulu) 5. Burnt Offerings (Tubi) 4. Talk to Me (RENT) 3. The Empty Man (Hulu) 2. Behind the Mask (SHUDDER, AMC+) 1. The Guest ($1.99 Rental)